Non-Toxic Beauty Products I’m Loving

Share on twitter
Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on pinterest
Share on tumblr
Share on email
Share on print

One of my goals in 2019 is to become more aware of the products I’m putting on my skin and to begin to work on some of the products I use daily. I’ve found that finding effective non-toxic skincare is a bit challenging, BUT I think makeup has come a long way. So today I wanted to talk through some of the makeup products I recently found on Thrive Market and which items I’m OBSESSED with. And well…the items I wasn’t fan of at all.

With my recent Thrive Market order, I purchased 13 products and I wasn’t a fan of only 3 items, which I think is pretty damn good! I talked about it on a recent podcast, but I want to mention it here as well – When you start looking at what the FDA allows in skincare and makeup products, you’ll begin to notice that cosmetics companies may use almost any ingredient or raw material in their products without government review or approval (FDA 2005). That means you’ll find parabens, sulfates, formaldehyde, and a ton of other ingredients that are known to be harmful to the skin and the body. So damn scary!

But when you go to a store to shop for beauty products, it’s not like they have a non-toxic, clean beauty care isle to look through (yet!). And that means you’re forced to read ingredients labels with 40 ingredients in them which makes it pretty easy to give up and just purchase whatever is in your hands. Luckily Thrive Market does all the ingredient list reading for you! When you log on to Thrive Market , you’ll find the Beauty Tab with products that are cruelty-free, non-toxic, fragrance-free, hypoallergenic, paraben-free, and phthalate-free. That way you can feel good about the products you are purchasing without all the unknowns! And the best part is that Thrive Market offers many of these items below MSRP!!

PaleOMG - Non-Toxic Beauty Products I'm Loving

Now let’s talk about some of the items I recently found, the good and the bad! First I wanted to talk about the makeup I am OBSESSED with and using daily –

  • Eco Lips Brown Sugar Lip Scrub (20% off!) – Ever since being on accutane back in 2014, my lips peel like CRAZY! With the dry weather in Colorado plus the medication, my lips have never been the same. And the only thing that preps them for a pretty lipstick is a lip scrub! This is a great one that uses gluten free, fair trade ingredients.
  • W3LL PEOPLE Bio Tint Multi-Action Moisturizer with SPF 30 #2, Light – I’m OBSESSED and absolutely in love with this tinted moisturizer. I’ve been pretty hooked on my normal tinted moisturizer so I was hesitant to even give this a go. But now I’m so glad I did! I’ve heard a lot of great things about W3LL PEOPLE and now I understand why. This tinted moisturizer gives amazing hydration, coverage, and looks amazing all day long! I will now be using this daily!
  • W3LL PEOPLE Bio Brightener Invisible Powder – To set my tinted moisturizer, I’ve been using this invisible powder just to keep the tinted moisturizer in place. It sets the skin without making the makeup look heavy, and it only has 5 different ingredients in it!
  • Mineral Fusion Espresso Gold Eye Shadow Trio (30% off!) – I’m IN LOVE with this 3-shade eyeshadow palette. These are the three main colors I use anytime I use any palette out there but now it’s in this one little compact palette AND it’s gluten-free, dye and color addictive-free, hypoallergenic, and paraben-free. But the best part is that is stays in place and looks good all day. It’s amazing!
  • W3LL PEOPLE Nudist Lip Butter #0 – Natural – I mentioned above that I have some issues with constantly peeling lips and this lip butter is a great alternatives to many different chapsticks out there since it’s non-toxic and paraben-free!
  • Mineral Hygienics Love Story Lip Liner (28% off!) – The older I get, the less I like to use bright lipstick. It just doesn’t look that good on me. And because of that, I’ve been looking for more neutral colors that give me a little extra color without making me look like I’m trying to look younger than I am. And this soft pink hue is the perfect color without looking over the top!
  • Mineral Fusion Ripe Lipstick Butter (31% off!) – And to go on top of the lip liner, I used this super clean lipstick butter to go on top! It’s great on it’s own or on top of a lipstick, and it keeps the lips super hydrated! I love this because I didn’t feel like it dried my lips out like most lipsticks on the market. And it’s gluten-free, dye and color addictive-free, hypoallergenic, and paraben-free.

PaleOMG - Non-Toxic Beauty Products I'm Loving

Now these are items I’m loving, just not using every single day –

  • Andalou Naturals 1000 Roses CC Cream Color + Correct Sheer Nude, SPF 30 (20% off!) – I really love this CC cream, especially since I love all things Andalou creates! The coverage is amazing and it goes smooth throughout. Plus it’s gluten-free, non-GMO, and it’s a women-owned business. LOVE that part about Andalou. The only reason I’m not using it daily is because I prefer a tinted moisturizer to a CC cream.
  • Mineral Hygienics Blemish Wonder Concealer (28% off!) – This powder is great for concealing dark circles, blemishes, age spots, rosacia, acne, and other skin conditions, and it won’t accentuate fine lines, wrinkles or pores. I use this whenever I have a blemish that is red or darker in color and it hides it right away!
  • No Miss Cosmetics Black Diamond Liquid Eyeliner (47% off!) – I really liked this eyeliner and I will use it whenever I’m out of my other eyeliner. The tip is thin so you can get a really accurate line which is what I want in an eyeliner. Plus it’s non-toxic and fragrance-free!

PaleOMG - Non-Toxic Beauty Products I'm Loving

And these are the products I was not impressed with –

  • W3LL PEOPLE Expressionist Liquid Eyeliner – I didn’t think the tip was thin enough on this eyeliner and it didn’t go on very smooth.
  • W3LL PEOPLE Expressionist Mascara Black – This mascara was recommended by a reader so I had great hopes for it, but I HATED it. If I’m not wearing lashes and just wearing mascara by itself, I want my lashes to look long, full, and thick, and this mascara did none of that. It made my lashes look thin and kind of straggly. I was super disappointed.
  • RMS Beauty Defining Mascara, Black – I felt the same exact way about this mascara as well. No fullness, length or volume. This mascara disappointed me, as well.

But loving 10 out of the 13 items I purchased is pretty damn good! Now I can take a step in the right direction when it comes to the tinted moisturizer I’m using daily, eyeshadow I wear whenever I get dressed up, and the lip liner and color I use regularly! I’m definitely not to the point that I’m using all non-toxic skincare brands, but I’m doing pretty good in the makeup department, and I can thank Thrive Market for most of that! And since Thrive Market is where I get some of my favorite food brands and products, now I can just add my makeup to my cart along with everything else, instead of having to go into a store! If you haven’t tried out Thrive Market yet, not only will you get up to 30% off your Thrive Market’s prices, but today you can get an EXTRA 25% off your first order + free 30 day trial! Thrive Market offers so much more than just pantry staples and I’ve loved finding new products each month! Can’t wait to share even more with you guys in the future!


This post is brought to you by Thrive Market. It contains some affiliate links and I may be compensated for this post, but all opinions are my own. This compensation helps with expenses to keep this blog up and running! Thank you for all your support!

Share on twitter
Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on pinterest
Share on tumblr
Share on email
Share on print

Oh, Hi! I’m Juli.

I’m a food hoarder. And a really bad dancer. If you don’t know me well, you will probably not understand my humor. Therefore, I apologize ahead of time. Thanks for listening to my ramblings of my ever-changing life and trusting my kitchen mishaps. Your trust in me is appreciated.


33 thoughts on “Non-Toxic Beauty Products I’m Loving”

  1. Jennifer McCoy

    Thank you Juli! I’ve been using Beauty Counter products and while I really like many of them, they are a bit pricey. There are some I’m in love with and won’t change, but there are others that I’m willing to look for alternatives! Thanks again for EVERYTHING you do.

  2. So glad to hear you posting about non toxic makeup. I switched out my makeup a year and half ago. I’ve had a hard time finding stuff compatible to the toxic stuff but for the most part you have to shop online so that makes it harder than normal. Just wanted to let you know Mineral Fusions mascara is pretty good. I hated the W3ll eyeliner as well as it made a mess with my eyes! The organic bunny on insta is a great resource for non toxic makeup!

  3. Love this! Since you didn’t love the two mascaras you bought, I’m curious as to what your favorite ones are. Thanks!

    1. right now, i use better than sex and loreal telescopic together, but they are definitely not non-toxic haha. still hunting. but i mostly just wear lashes instead of wearing mascara

  4. Christine Romano

    There’s an app called Think Dirty. You can search products by scannning barcodes or entering product names. It will give you a clean rating and a break down of the ingredients and their ratings.

  5. I’m a big fan of the W3ll People Tinted Moisturizer too. I add a few drops of face oil to it and mix it in my palm then use my fingertips to apply. I’ve tried ALL the clean beauty mascaras and my favorite by far is Honest Beauty! It has a primer on one end and it actually adds length, volume, and stays put! Thanks for this post!

  6. Great feedback on products! I’ve been on the hunt for a safer mascara for a long time and I’m still looking. Le sigh.

  7. Juli – I’d recommend trying Honest Beauty’s mascara if you haven’t already. I’ve tried a bunch of non-toxic mascaras and it’s the only one that I feel like actually holds up to conventional brands, performance-wise. And it’s only $15!

  8. Great post. I’ve finally transitioned almost all my makeup to green beauty (just need to find a good brow one). Im like you and like my lashes more dramatic since I dont wear much else for makeup. For green beauty my #1 pick is Lily Lolo and #2 would be Honest Beauty or Tarte. Other mascaras I’ve tried that were just meh: Mineral Fusion, Well People, Ilia (good for a natural looking lash), Beauty Counter (the worst mascara, a lot of their other products are great though)

  9. Awesome reviews! Thank you for this post. Finding good natural makeup can be tricky (and expensive). Appreciate that you’ve done the legwork for us here. I noticed that both mascaras you tried were disappointing, so thought I’d share what I feel is a great option. Check out Jessica Alba’s The Honest Co. They have a great mascara and primer in one, called extreme length mascara and primer. It is a 2 step mascara so it takes a little longer to apply, but is the best safe mascara I’ve been able to find. It is free of parabens, paraffins, silicones, and fragrances. It is actually sold out on their website right now due to popular demand. lol Some Target stores carry it and is sometimes available on Amazon. Been following you for years and own all of your cookbooks. Keep up the great work chic! P.S. Jackson is the best. I always show my hubby when he is in your blog pics. Can’t wait to get a Frenchie myself in a few months!

  10. I LOVE Bite Beauty’s agave lip mask for dry lips! It gets really dry here in Ohio in the winter, and the lip mask has worked really well to prevent my lips from getting dried out and cracking. Highly recommend putting it on before bed. Your lips will be so soft when you wake up. It’s a little pricey, but the tube lasts forever, so I think it’s worth it. Thanks for your reviews!

      1. I have loved the Bite Beauty lip mask, so definitely worth a try – I checked out the ingredients, and the main one is lanolin, so if you want to dodge the price tag and don’t mind grabbing a maternity product, pick up a tube of lanolin boob cream from the baby section at Target 🙂 It’s been working just as well and lasts forever! I also mix a bit in with my hand lotion, and I had zero problems with hang nails and cracked skin this winter – such a relief.

  11. Off topic a bit but where in town did you get your eyebrows microbladed if you don’t mind me asking?! They look fantastic. I’m in Denver as well and have been thinking of getting mine done.

    Love your blog and recipes!

  12. I have switched all of my makeup (except mascara – still need to try theirs) to Root Pretty, a small woman-owned company in Iowa. I also use some of their skincare products. It’s good stuff!!

  13. How would you compare the Jane Iredale Glow Time BB Cream to the mineral fusion tinted moisturizer? I know you used to use Jane Iredale’s before! Thanks for this post I love to have new beauty products to try!

    1. i think they tinted moisturizer is definitely more hydrating and less heavy than the bb cream BUT it gives just as great coverage!! i’m seriously SO OBSESSED with it right now!

  14. You should try Tarte Amazonian clay mascara, it rated a 4 on EWG, with 10 being the most toxic. I use it and it’s amazing.

  15. Hi!!

    I’m going crazy looking for a product you use and did a review on and can’t find it!! It’s the eyebrow tinting kit you use in-between treatments. I have really light eyebrows and I want to start tinting them and thought I would look into what your using. THANK YOU!! Hope you are having fun in Cabo!!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Sign up for my PaleOMG newsletter to get recipes,
discounts, and stories straight to your inbox for FREE!

Greek Chicken Bowls

5.0 rating
6 reviews




[Edit recipe]




[Edit recipe]

Don't Miss A Bite!

Sign up for my PaleOMG newsletter to get recipes, discounts, and stories straight to your inbox for FREE!